Great Pizza Places

Wisconsin · By City

Best Pizza in Milwaukee

The most essential pies in Milwaukee, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Zaffiro's Pizza pizza
106
Tavern-style

Zaffiro's Pizza

Milwaukee, WI

Cracker-thin tavern pies since 1954 — a Milwaukee icon.

9.4
Editorial Score
Ian's Pizza pizza
131
Artisan

Ian's Pizza

Milwaukee, WI

East Side late-night slice destination with famously eclectic toppings.

9.3
Editorial Score
Balistreri's Bluemound Inn pizza
246
Traditional

Balistreri's Bluemound Inn

Milwaukee, WI

Milwaukee institution since 1971 with a legendary cracker-thin crust.

9.1
Editorial Score
Zaffiro's Pizza pizza
326
Tavern-Style

Zaffiro's Pizza

Milwaukee, WI

9.1
Editorial Score
Pizza Man pizza
403
Artisan

Pizza Man

Milwaukee, WI

East Side pizzeria-and-wine-bar with a chef-driven topping menu.

9.0
Editorial Score
Salvatore's Pizzeria pizza
541
Neapolitan

Salvatore's Pizzeria

Milwaukee, WI

Suburban Neapolitan pies with imported ingredients.

8.8
Editorial Score
Transfer Pizzeria Cafe pizza
561
Neapolitan

Transfer Pizzeria Cafe

Milwaukee, WI

8.8
Editorial Score
Balistreri's Italian American Ristorante pizza
573
Tavern-Style

Balistreri's Italian American Ristorante

Milwaukee, WI

8.7
Editorial Score
Transfer Pizzeria Cafe pizza
648
Artisan

Transfer Pizzeria Cafe

Milwaukee, WI

Bay View craft pizzeria in a converted transfer station.

8.7
Editorial Score
Pizza Man pizza
701
Artisan

Pizza Man

Milwaukee, WI

8.6
Editorial Score
Santino's Little Italy pizza
709
New York

Santino's Little Italy

Milwaukee, WI

Downtown NY slice shop with foldable pies.

8.6
Editorial Score
Santino's Little Italy pizza
737
Tavern-Style

Santino's Little Italy

Milwaukee, WI

8.5
Editorial Score
DiSalvo's Pizza pizza
749
Pan

DiSalvo's Pizza

Milwaukee, WI

8.4
Editorial Score
DiSalvo's Pizzeria pizza
750
Traditional

DiSalvo's Pizzeria

Milwaukee, WI

South-side family-run institution with a thin, crispy crust.

8.4
Editorial Score
Classic Slice pizza
798
New York-Style

Classic Slice

Milwaukee, WI

8.3
Editorial Score
Classic Slice Pizzeria pizza
799
New York

Classic Slice Pizzeria

Milwaukee, WI

Bay View foldable NY slice destination.

8.3
Editorial Score
Glass Nickel Pizza pizza
854
Artisan

Glass Nickel Pizza

Milwaukee, WI

Madison-born chain with a wide-ranging topping menu and a solid crust.

8.1
Editorial Score