Wisconsin · By City

Best Pizza in Green Bay

The most essential pies in Green Bay, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team. We currently rank 10 pizzerias here, with Italian-American and Tavern leading the scene.

Ranked: Top 10
High score: 9.1
On the map: 10

List last updated September 2026

#1 in Green Bay

Gallagher's Pizza

Italian-American · Editorial score 9.1

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Italian-American

Gallagher's Pizza

Green Bay, WI

The thin, crisp crust is a Green Bay standard, holding up well under their well-known sausage topping. Sauce has a mild sweetness that pairs with a generous layer of cheese.

9.1

Editorial Score

Italian-American

Sammy's Pizza Green Bay

Green Bay, WI

The crust bakes to a nice chew with a crisp bottom, and the sauce carries a deep, long-simmered flavor. Classic Italian sausage topping is the standout order here.

9.0

Editorial Score

Sicilian

Pope's Pizza

Green Bay, WI

The Sicilian-style pie has a notably thick, airy crust with good crunch on the bottom, distinct from the thinner local norm. Sauce is applied generously and holds its tang against

8.9

Editorial Score

Tavern

Jake's Pizza Green Bay

Green Bay, WI

The cracker-thin crust is cut into squares in classic Wisconsin tavern fashion, crisping evenly across the pie. Sauce is simple, letting the cheese and pepperoni carry the flavor.

8.8

Editorial Score

Tavern

Anduzzi's Sports Club

Green Bay, WI

The thin crust crisps up well under a generous topping load, built for sharing during game day. Sauce is basic but consistent, nothing flashy but reliably cooked.

8.7

Editorial Score

Craft

Titletown Brewing Co. Pizza

Green Bay, WI

The thin crust gets a good char from the brewery's wood-fired oven, a solid pairing with their house beers. Toppings are simple and fresh, keeping the focus on the crust.

8.5

Editorial Score

Italian-American

Rocco's Pizza Green Bay

Green Bay, WI

The crust bakes crisp on the bottom with a decent chew, holding up under classic pepperoni and sausage. Sauce is straightforward and slightly sweet.

8.4

Editorial Score

Tavern

Mihm's Pizza

Green Bay, WI

The cracker-thin crust holds a good crunch across the whole square-cut pie, a classic Wisconsin tavern style. Toppings are basic but well distributed edge to edge.

8.3

Editorial Score

Italian-American

Ferdinand's Pizza

Green Bay, WI

The crust is medium-thick with an even bake and a mildly sweet house sauce typical of the region. Classic combo toppings are generously portioned.

8.2

Editorial Score

Tavern

Cranky Pat's Pizzeria & Pub

Green Bay, WI

A Wisconsin pizzeria and pub serving tavern-style pizza with tomato, garlic-butter or barbecue sauce.

8.1

Editorial Score

Green Bay pizza by style

Best Tavern & Bar in Green Bay (4)Best Italian-American in Green Bay (4)

Green Bay pizza FAQ

What is the best pizza in Green Bay?

Our editorial team currently ranks Gallagher's Pizza as the best pizza in Green Bay, Wisconsin. The thin, crisp crust is a Green Bay standard, holding up well under their well-known sausage topping. Sauce has a mild sweetness that pairs with a generous layer of cheese.

What style of pizza is Green Bay known for?

Italian-American is the most common style among our ranked Green Bay pizzerias (4 of 10). The top-rated Italian-American spot is Gallagher's Pizza.

Where can I get great budget-friendly pizza in Green Bay?

Gallagher's Pizza is the highest-scoring budget-friendly ($) pizzeria on our Green Bay list, with an editorial score of 9.1.

How many pizza places does Great Pizza Places rank in Green Bay?

We currently rank the top 10 pizza places in Green Bay, Wisconsin, scored on crust, sauce, cheese, ingredients, and consistency.

How does Great Pizza Places rank pizzerias in Green Bay?

Every Green Bay pizzeria is reviewed on five criteria — crust, sauce, cheese, ingredients, and consistency — combined into an editorial score from 0 to 10. Rankings are updated as we revisit and add new places.

More pizza in Wisconsin

Best in Milwaukee Best in Madison Best in Appleton Best in Sun Prairie All cities →