Great Pizza Places

Wisconsin · By City

Best Pizza in Appleton

The most essential pies in Appleton, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Stuc's Pizza Restaurant pizza
0
Traditional

Stuc's Pizza Restaurant

Appleton, WI

Award-winning pizza made from scratch with unique family recipes since 1991.

9.6
Editorial Score
Christiano's Pizza pizza
0
Wood-fired

Christiano's Pizza

Appleton, WI

Brick oven pizza with locations across the Fox Valley.

9.4
Editorial Score
Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub pizza
0
Traditional

Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub

Appleton, WI

Family-friendly pizzeria and pub with a lively local crowd.

9.2
Editorial Score
Frank's Pizza Palace pizza
0
Traditional

Frank's Pizza Palace

Appleton, WI

Continuously voted #1 best pizza in the Fox Cities, since decades.

8.9
Editorial Score
Pierri Pizza pizza
0
Traditional

Pierri Pizza

Appleton, WI

Thin, crispy crust pizza famous for real mushrooms and homemade sausage.

8.7
Editorial Score
Glory Days Pizza pizza
0
Craft

Glory Days Pizza

Appleton, WI

Casual pizza spot with a strong craft beer selection.

8.5
Editorial Score
Cranky Pat's Pizza Pub pizza
0
Tavern

Cranky Pat's Pizza Pub

Appleton, WI

Downtown Appleton tavern-style pizza and pub fare.

8.3
Editorial Score
Mucky Duck Shanty pizza
0
Traditional

Mucky Duck Shanty

Appleton, WI

Local eatery serving hearty traditional pizza alongside pub fare.

8.1
Editorial Score
Nick's Pizza pizza
0
Traditional

Nick's Pizza

Appleton, WI

Family-owned neighborhood pizzeria with classic recipes.

7.8
Editorial Score
Ranch House Pizza pizza
0
Traditional

Ranch House Pizza

Appleton, WI

Long-standing west-side Appleton pizza favorite.

7.6
Editorial Score