Great Pizza Places

New York · By City

Best Pizza in Yonkers

The most essential pies in Yonkers, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Rocco & Joe's pizza
0
New York

Rocco & Joe's

Yonkers, NY

Family shop whose brick-oven pies are a Central Yonkers institution.

9.3
Editorial Score
Frankie & Fanucci's Wood Oven Pizzeria pizza
0
Neapolitan

Frankie & Fanucci's Wood Oven Pizzeria

Yonkers, NY

Wood-oven pizzeria drawing lower-Westchester diners for Neapolitan-leaning pies.

9.2
Editorial Score
Nick's Pizza pizza
0
New York

Nick's Pizza

Yonkers, NY

Central Park Ave counter with a slice that Yonkers regulars measure others against.

9.0
Editorial Score
Louie & Ernie's Pizza pizza
0
New York

Louie & Ernie's Pizza

Yonkers, NY

Bronx-adjacent counter that has served southern Westchester for generations.

8.9
Editorial Score
Mario's Pizza pizza
0
New York

Mario's Pizza

Yonkers, NY

Downtown Yonkers slice shop whose lunch line moves fast and never disappoints.

8.8
Editorial Score
Primavera Pizza & Restaurant pizza
0
New York

Primavera Pizza & Restaurant

Yonkers, NY

Yonkers Ave counter with a huge menu and a slice that outperforms the sit-down operation.

8.7
Editorial Score
Pete & Elda's pizza
0
Bar pizza

Pete & Elda's

Yonkers, NY

Bar-pie counter modeled on the Jersey Shore classic, with paper-thin crackery pies.

8.6
Editorial Score
Tuscany Pizzeria pizza
0
New York

Tuscany Pizzeria

Yonkers, NY

McLean Ave institution whose Sicilian pie is the neighborhood's Friday-night order.

8.5
Editorial Score
Caruso Restaurant & Pizza pizza
0
New York

Caruso Restaurant & Pizza

Yonkers, NY

Central Ave sit-down whose sausage-and-onion pie is a genuine Westchester sleeper.

8.4
Editorial Score
Gigio's Pizza pizza
0
New York

Gigio's Pizza

Yonkers, NY

Central Ave counter turning out reliable NY-style slices for the lower Westchester lunch crowd.

8.3
Editorial Score