Great Pizza Places

New York · By City

Best Pizza in New York City

The essential pies across all five boroughs — Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, and Staten Island — ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Lucali pizza
1
Neo-Neapolitan

Lucali

Brooklyn, NY

A candle-lit Carroll Gardens institution where Mark Iacono hand-stretches every pie behind a marble counter.

9.7
Editorial Score
L'industrie Pizzeria pizza
3
New York

L'industrie Pizzeria

Brooklyn, NY

Williamsburg slice shop redefining the modern NY square.

9.6
Editorial Score
Di Fara Pizza pizza
14
New York

Di Fara Pizza

Brooklyn, NY

Dom DeMarco's Midwood temple to the slice — basil snipped over each pie tableside since 1965.

9.5
Editorial Score
Mama's Too pizza
20
Sicilian

Mama's Too

New York, NY

Upper West Side square-slice phenom.

9.5
Editorial Score
Joe's Pizza pizza
64
New York

Joe's Pizza

New York, NY

The definitive Greenwich Village slice since 1975 — foldable, well-charred, uncomplicated perfection.

9.4
Editorial Score
Roberta's pizza
94
Neo-Neapolitan

Roberta's

Brooklyn, NY

Bushwick wood-fired pioneer with cult-favorite specials.

9.4
Editorial Score
Scarr's Pizza pizza
97
New York

Scarr's Pizza

New York, NY

Scarr Pimentel's grain-mill-driven slice shop on the LES.

9.4
Editorial Score
John's of Bleecker Street pizza
136
New York

John's of Bleecker Street

New York, NY

Coal-fired Greenwich Village institution since 1929.

9.3
Editorial Score
Prince Street Pizza pizza
175
Sicilian

Prince Street Pizza

New York, NY

The definitive Nolita square slice — pepperoni cups on a spongy, sauce-first crust.

9.3
Editorial Score
Joe's Pizza pizza
273
New York

Joe's Pizza

New York, NY

The benchmark for the New York street slice since 1975, just off Bleecker.

9.1
Editorial Score