Great Pizza Places

New York · By City

Best Pizza in Rochester

The most essential pies in Rochester, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria pizza
0
Rochester-style

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Rochester, NY

Regional chain born in Chili whose oversized rectangular pies are a Rochester default.

9.3
Editorial Score
Pontillo's Pizzeria pizza
0
Rochester-style

Pontillo's Pizzeria

Rochester, NY

Family-run chain founded in 1947 whose Old World pie is a Monroe County institution.

9.2
Editorial Score
Napa Wood Fired Pizzeria pizza
0
Neapolitan

Napa Wood Fired Pizzeria

Rochester, NY

Pittsford wood-oven counter turning out the region's most technically serious Neapolitan pies.

9.1
Editorial Score
Pizza Stop pizza
0
New York

Pizza Stop

Rochester, NY

Downtown by-the-slice counter that has anchored Rochester's core for decades.

9.0
Editorial Score
Mark's Pizzeria pizza
0
Rochester-style

Mark's Pizzeria

Rochester, NY

Rochester-founded chain whose original pies still show up in the University Ave dining room.

8.8
Editorial Score
Peppino's Restaurant & Pizzeria pizza
0
New York

Peppino's Restaurant & Pizzeria

Rochester, NY

Fairport neighborhood restaurant with a slice program that outpaces the strip-mall setting.

8.7
Editorial Score
Fiamma Centro Pizzeria pizza
0
Neapolitan

Fiamma Centro Pizzeria

Rochester, NY

West-side wood-oven counter run by an ex-Napa alum with a shorter, sharper menu.

8.6
Editorial Score
Perri's Pizzeria pizza
0
Rochester-style

Perri's Pizzeria

Rochester, NY

Long-running Greece Ridge neighborhood standby with a following that spans three generations.

8.5
Editorial Score
Aversa's Pizzeria pizza
0
Rochester-style

Aversa's Pizzeria

Rochester, NY

Henrietta counter shop whose oversized round pies are a Route 15 staple.

8.4
Editorial Score
Nick's Pizzeria pizza
0
New York

Nick's Pizzeria

Rochester, NY

Webster counter shop making a case for east-side Rochester slice supremacy.

8.3
Editorial Score