Great Pizza Places

Florida · By City

Best Pizza in Tallahassee

The most essential pies in Tallahassee, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Gaines Street Pies pizza
0
Craft

Gaines Street Pies

Tallahassee, FL

Ingredient-obsessed shop that scratch-makes everything from meatballs to ranch.

9.6
Editorial Score
Brooklyn Pizza pizza
0
New York

Brooklyn Pizza

Tallahassee, FL

Three-decade Tallahassee staple for real New York-style pizza.

9.4
Editorial Score
Isabella's Pizzeria Napoletana pizza
0
Neapolitan

Isabella's Pizzeria Napoletana

Tallahassee, FL

Cozy Gaines Street spot turning out authentic Neapolitan pies.

9.2
Editorial Score
Village Pizza & Pasta pizza
0
New York

Village Pizza & Pasta

Tallahassee, FL

Family-owned brick-oven kitchen with authentic NY-style pies.

8.9
Editorial Score
Momo's Pizza pizza
0
New York

Momo's Pizza

Tallahassee, FL

Legendary oversized foldable slices loved by generations of FSU students.

8.7
Editorial Score
Five Star Pizza pizza
0
Traditional

Five Star Pizza

Tallahassee, FL

Late-night value pies with generously sized extra-large pizzas.

8.5
Editorial Score
Dave's Pizza Garage pizza
0
Traditional

Dave's Pizza Garage

Tallahassee, FL

Northeast Tallahassee garage-themed shop turning out scratch-made pies.

8.3
Editorial Score
Little Italy Pizzeria & Restaurant pizza
0
Italian-American

Little Italy Pizzeria & Restaurant

Tallahassee, FL

Family-owned Tallahassee institution since 1987 serving homestyle Italian pizzas.

8.1
Editorial Score
Munchies Pizza pizza
0
New York

Munchies Pizza

Tallahassee, FL

Late-night FSU-area spot slinging New York-style slices behind the Strip.

7.8
Editorial Score
Brickyard Pizzeria pizza
0
Traditional

Brickyard Pizzeria

Tallahassee, FL

Neighborhood Italian pizzeria serving authentic pies in northeast Tallahassee.

7.6
Editorial Score