Florida · By City
Best Pizza in Tallahassee
The most essential pies in Tallahassee, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team. We currently rank 10 pizzerias here, with New York and Traditional leading the scene.
- Ranked
- Top 10
- High score
- 9.6
- On the map
- 10
List last updated September 2026
#1 in Tallahassee
Gaines Street Pies
Craft · Editorial score 9.6
Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.
Tallahassee pizza by style
Tallahassee pizza FAQ
What is the best pizza in Tallahassee?
Our editorial team currently ranks Gaines Street Pies as the best pizza in Tallahassee, Florida. Ingredient-obsessed shop that scratch-makes everything from meatballs to ranch.
What style of pizza is Tallahassee known for?
New York is the most common style among our ranked Tallahassee pizzerias (4 of 10). The top-rated New York spot is Brooklyn Pizza.
Where can I get great budget-friendly pizza in Tallahassee?
Gaines Street Pies is the highest-scoring budget-friendly ($) pizzeria on our Tallahassee list, with an editorial score of 9.6.
How many pizza places does Great Pizza Places rank in Tallahassee?
We currently rank the top 10 pizza places in Tallahassee, Florida, scored on crust, sauce, cheese, ingredients, and consistency.
How does Great Pizza Places rank pizzerias in Tallahassee?
Every Tallahassee pizzeria is reviewed on five criteria — crust, sauce, cheese, ingredients, and consistency — combined into an editorial score from 0 to 10. Rankings are updated as we revisit and add new places.