Best pizza in Tallahassee · New York guide
Best New York Pizza in Tallahassee
The 4 best New York pizzerias in Tallahassee, Florida, ranked by editorial score. Large, thin, and foldable — the slice that built America's pizza culture. A crisp-yet-pliable crust, a balanced tomato sauce, and low-moisture mozzarella, sold by the slice and eaten on the move.
1
New York
Brooklyn Pizza
Tallahassee, FL
Three-decade Tallahassee staple for real New York-style pizza.
9.4
Editorial Score
2
New York
Village Pizza & Pasta
Tallahassee, FL
Family-owned brick-oven kitchen with authentic NY-style pies.
8.9
Editorial Score
3
New York
Momo's Pizza
Tallahassee, FL
Legendary oversized foldable slices loved by generations of FSU students.
8.7
Editorial Score
4
New York
Munchies Pizza
Tallahassee, FL
Late-night FSU-area spot slinging New York-style slices behind the Strip.
7.8
Editorial Score