Best pizza in Tallahassee · Italian-American guide
Best Italian-American Pizza in Tallahassee
The 4 best Italian-American pizzerias in Tallahassee, Florida, ranked by editorial score. The red-sauce pizzeria tradition carried across America by Italian immigrants: generous cheese, a sturdy crust, and recipes passed down for generations. This is the neighborhood pizza most of the country grew up on.
1
Traditional
Five Star Pizza
Tallahassee, FL
Late-night value pies with generously sized extra-large pizzas.
8.5
Editorial Score
2
Traditional
Dave's Pizza Garage
Tallahassee, FL
Northeast Tallahassee garage-themed shop turning out scratch-made pies.
8.3
Editorial Score
3
Italian-American
Little Italy Pizzeria & Restaurant
Tallahassee, FL
Family-owned Tallahassee institution since 1987 serving homestyle Italian pizzas.
8.1
Editorial Score
4
Traditional
Brickyard Pizzeria
Tallahassee, FL
Neighborhood Italian pizzeria serving authentic pies in northeast Tallahassee.
7.6
Editorial Score