Ohio · By City

Best Pizza in Dayton

The most essential pies in Dayton, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team. We currently rank 10 pizzerias here, with Italian-American and Neapolitan leading the scene.

Ranked: Top 10
High score: 9.1
On the map: 10

List last updated September 2026

#1 in Dayton

Cassano's Pizza King

Italian-American · Editorial score 9.1

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Italian-American

Cassano's Pizza King

Dayton, OH

The square-cut party pizza has a thin, buttery crust that's a Dayton institution. The tangy house sauce is what locals recognize immediately, sweeter and spicier than most.

9.1

Editorial Score

Italian-American

Marion's Piazza

Dayton, OH

The pan crust is thick, buttery, and crisp on the bottom without being greasy. Loaded pies come with generous, evenly distributed toppings under a well-seasoned sauce.

9.0

Editorial Score

Neapolitan

Old Scratch Pizza

Dayton, OH

The leopard-charred crust puffs beautifully around the edges while staying pliable in the center. San Marzano-based sauce is bright and not overly salty against fresh mozzarella.

8.9

Editorial Score

Italian-American

Joe's Pizzeria Dayton

Dayton, OH

The thin, cracker-style crust is baked well past golden for a real crunch. The sauce leans sweet-tangy, a distinct old-school Dayton flavor.

8.8

Editorial Score

Italian-American

Pizza Factory Dayton

Dayton, OH

The dough is proofed properly so the crust puffs up light with a slight chew. Sauce is a well-balanced tomato base without excess sweetness.

8.7

Editorial Score

Californian

Figlio

Dayton, OH

The thin, blistered crust holds up under upscale toppings like goat cheese and fig without turning soggy. Flavor combinations lean more inventive than traditional, but the crust te

8.5

Editorial Score

Italian-American

DeLucia's Pizza

Dayton, OH

The crust is medium-thick with a satisfying chew and a mildly sweet sauce typical of the region's older pizzerias. Toppings are simple, classic combinations done well.

8.4

Editorial Score

Craft

Yellow Cab Pizza Co

Dayton, OH

The thin, crisp crust holds up to a build-your-own approach with lots of topping combinations. Sauce is a straightforward tomato base that doesn't compete with whatever you pile on

8.3

Editorial Score

Italian-American

Brown Street Pizza

Dayton, OH

The crust is thin to medium with decent crispness at the edge, nothing fancy but reliably cooked through. Classic toppings like pepperoni and sausage come in generous portions.

8.2

Editorial Score

Italian-American

Troy Street Pizza & Subs

Dayton, OH

The pan-style crust is thick and buttery on the bottom, similar to Dayton's classic style. Sauce is tangy-sweet and pairs well with a heavy layer of cheese.

8.1

Editorial Score

Dayton pizza by style

Best Italian-American in Dayton (7)

Dayton pizza FAQ

What is the best pizza in Dayton?

Our editorial team currently ranks Cassano's Pizza King as the best pizza in Dayton, Ohio. The square-cut party pizza has a thin, buttery crust that's a Dayton institution. The tangy house sauce is what locals recognize immediately, sweeter and spicier than most.

What style of pizza is Dayton known for?

Italian-American is the most common style among our ranked Dayton pizzerias (7 of 10). The top-rated Italian-American spot is Cassano's Pizza King.

Where can I get great budget-friendly pizza in Dayton?

Cassano's Pizza King is the highest-scoring budget-friendly ($) pizzeria on our Dayton list, with an editorial score of 9.1.

How many pizza places does Great Pizza Places rank in Dayton?

We currently rank the top 10 pizza places in Dayton, Ohio, scored on crust, sauce, cheese, ingredients, and consistency.

How does Great Pizza Places rank pizzerias in Dayton?

Every Dayton pizzeria is reviewed on five criteria — crust, sauce, cheese, ingredients, and consistency — combined into an editorial score from 0 to 10. Rankings are updated as we revisit and add new places.

More pizza in Ohio

Best in Columbus Best in Cleveland Best in Cincinnati Best in Canton Best in Akron Best in Toledo All cities →