Great Pizza Places

Ohio · By City

Best Pizza in Columbus

The most essential pies in Columbus, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Harvest Pizzeria pizza
57
Artisan

Harvest Pizzeria

Columbus, OH

Wood-fired pies in a chef-driven German Village room.

9.4
Editorial Score
Adriatico's New York Style Pizza pizza
108
New York

Adriatico's New York Style Pizza

Columbus, OH

OSU campus foldable NY slice destination with a cult following.

9.3
Editorial Score
Harvest Pizzeria pizza
268
Wood-Fired

Harvest Pizzeria

Columbus, OH

Seasonal, locally sourced wood-fired pies that put Columbus on the map.

9.1
Editorial Score
Massey's Pizza pizza
280
Traditional

Massey's Pizza

Columbus, OH

Columbus institution since 1949 with a beloved thin crust.

9.1
Editorial Score
Dewey's Pizza pizza
349
Artisan

Dewey's Pizza

Columbus, OH

Grandview craft pies with a chef-driven topping menu.

9.0
Editorial Score
Taglio Pizza pizza
556
Roman

Taglio Pizza

Columbus, OH

Clintonville Roman-style pizza al taglio with a proper crackly crust.

8.8
Editorial Score
A Tavola pizza
571
Neapolitan

A Tavola

Columbus, OH

Grandview VPN-inspired Neapolitan pies with a bright crust.

8.7
Editorial Score
Adriatico's New York Style Pizza pizza
572
New York

Adriatico's New York Style Pizza

Columbus, OH

Buckeye-beloved giant New York pies near OSU.

8.7
Editorial Score
Massey's Pizza pizza
688
Columbus

Massey's Pizza

Columbus, OH

Edge-to-edge cup-and-char pepperoni on a thin Columbus-style crust.

8.6
Editorial Score
Pizza 1889 pizza
698
Neapolitan

Pizza 1889

Columbus, OH

Short North VPN-certified Neapolitan pies.

8.6
Editorial Score
Citizen Pie pizza
748
Neapolitan

Citizen Pie

Columbus, OH

Cleveland wood-fired Neapolitan pies with a chef-driven approach.

8.4
Editorial Score
Il Rione pizza
810
Neapolitan

Il Rione

Columbus, OH

Detroit Shoreway VPN-inspired Neapolitan pies.

8.3
Editorial Score
Vero Pizza Napoletana pizza
877
Neapolitan

Vero Pizza Napoletana

Columbus, OH

Cedar-Fairmount VPN-certified Neapolitan destination.

8.1
Editorial Score