Great Pizza Places

New Jersey · By City

Best Pizza in Princeton

The most essential pies in Princeton, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Nomad Pizza pizza
0
Wood-fired

Nomad Pizza

Princeton, NJ

Wood-fired brick-oven pies made with local, organic ingredients weekly.

9.6
Editorial Score
Conte's Pizza and Bar pizza
0
Tavern

Conte's Pizza and Bar

Princeton, NJ

Beloved 75-year-old tavern pizzeria, a true Princeton institution.

9.4
Editorial Score
Alfonso's Pizzeria & Restaurant pizza
0
Italian-American

Alfonso's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Princeton, NJ

Longstanding downtown pizzeria known for classic Italian-American pies.

9.2
Editorial Score
Princeton Pizza Star pizza
0
Italian-American

Princeton Pizza Star

Princeton, NJ

Cozy spot serving authentic Italian-style pizza with a warm welcome.

8.9
Editorial Score
Pizza Den pizza
0
New York

Pizza Den

Princeton, NJ

In-house dough and organic flour set apart this popular Nassau Street slice shop.

8.7
Editorial Score
Tiger Pizza pizza
0
New York

Tiger Pizza

Princeton, NJ

Late-night student favorite near campus for cheap, fast New York-style slices.

8.5
Editorial Score
Teresa's Caffe pizza
0
Italian-American

Teresa's Caffe

Princeton, NJ

Palmer Square trattoria emphasizing wood-fired pizza alongside pasta and wine.

8.3
Editorial Score
Mediterra pizza
0
Wood-fired

Mediterra

Princeton, NJ

Upscale Mediterranean dining room offering wood-fired pizzas among its Italian-Spanish menu.

8.1
Editorial Score
Alfonso's Pizzeria and Restaurant pizza
0
Italian-American

Alfonso's Pizzeria and Restaurant

Princeton, NJ

Family-run pizzeria serving classic Italian-American pies just outside downtown Princeton.

7.8
Editorial Score