Great Pizza Places

New Jersey · By City

Best Pizza in Paterson

The most essential pies in Paterson, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Taormina Pizzeria & Restaurant pizza
0
New York

Taormina Pizzeria & Restaurant

Paterson, NJ

Family-owned since 1981, known for a distinctive thicker-crust New York pie.

9.6
Editorial Score
Patsy's Tavern & Restaurant pizza
0
Tavern

Patsy's Tavern & Restaurant

Paterson, NJ

Old-fashioned tavern serving classic handmade Italian fare since 1931.

9.4
Editorial Score
Broadway Pizza pizza
0
New York

Broadway Pizza

Paterson, NJ

Decades-old Paterson institution known for huge slices and a crispy crust.

9.2
Editorial Score
Tony's Pizza pizza
0
New York

Tony's Pizza

Paterson, NJ

Neighborhood pizzeria popular for deal combos and classic traditional pies.

8.9
Editorial Score
Lefty's Pizzeria and Restaurant pizza
0
Italian-American

Lefty's Pizzeria and Restaurant

Paterson, NJ

Casual local spot known for generous portions and fast delivery.

8.7
Editorial Score
Larios Restaurant and Pizza pizza
0
Italian-American

Larios Restaurant and Pizza

Paterson, NJ

Longstanding Paterson corner spot pairing Latin classics with hand-tossed pizza.

8.5
Editorial Score
Jersey Sub and Pizza pizza
0
New York

Jersey Sub and Pizza

Paterson, NJ

Neighborhood counter serving personal pizzas and hero sandwiches to local regulars.

8.3
Editorial Score
Bella's Bistro and Pizza pizza
0
Italian-American

Bella's Bistro and Pizza

Paterson, NJ

Casual bistro turning out classic red-sauce pizzas alongside Italian entrees.

8.1
Editorial Score
Bella Vista pizza
0
Italian-American

Bella Vista

Paterson, NJ

Neighborhood Italian-American eatery known for generous pies and family recipes.

7.8
Editorial Score