Great Pizza Places

Florida · By City

Best Pizza in Sarasota

The most essential pies in Sarasota, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Capo Pazzo Pizzeria pizza
0
New York

Capo Pazzo Pizzeria

Sarasota, FL

Family-run kitchen bringing authentic NYC-style pies to downtown Sarasota.

9.6
Editorial Score
Asaro's Pizzeria pizza
0
New York

Asaro's Pizzeria

Sarasota, FL

Family-focused spot serving authentic New York style Italian fare.

9.4
Editorial Score
Il Panificio pizza
0
Italian-American

Il Panificio

Sarasota, FL

Longtime Sarasota Magazine reader favorite for classic Italian bakery pies.

9.2
Editorial Score
Bavaro's Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria pizza
0
Neapolitan

Bavaro's Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria

Sarasota, FL

Florida's first traditional Neapolitan pizzeria, baking in a 100-year-old wood-fired recipe.

8.9
Editorial Score
Napule Sarasota pizza
0
Italian-American

Napule Sarasota

Sarasota, FL

Downtown Sarasota Italian spot with a devoted following for its pizza and pasta.

8.7
Editorial Score
Trattoria Bella Napoli pizza
0
Neapolitan

Trattoria Bella Napoli

Sarasota, FL

Family-owned trattoria bringing rustic Neapolitan-Italian pizza to Sarasota.

8.5
Editorial Score
Vesuvio pizza
0
Italian-American

Vesuvio

Sarasota, FL

Longtime Sarasota Italian restaurant with a dedicated pizza menu.

8.3
Editorial Score
Eleni's Pizza Works pizza
0
Traditional

Eleni's Pizza Works

Sarasota, FL

Family-run Greek kitchen and pizzeria slow-proofing dough for over 20 years.

8.1
Editorial Score
Solorzano's Pizzeria Gulf Gate pizza
0
Italian-American

Solorzano's Pizzeria Gulf Gate

Sarasota, FL

Gulf Gate Italian market and pizzeria rooted in a family recipe from Avellino, Italy.

7.8
Editorial Score
Tralia Pizza pizza
0
Artisan

Tralia Pizza

Sarasota, FL

Gulf Gate sourdough pizza shop that grew from a pandemic-era pop-up.

7.6
Editorial Score