Great Pizza Places

Florida · By City

Best Pizza in Fort Myers

The most essential pies in Fort Myers, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Capone's Coal Fired Pizza & Pasta pizza
0
Coal-fired

Capone's Coal Fired Pizza & Pasta

Fort Myers, FL

Prohibition-themed dining room serving crackly coal-fired pies.

9.6
Editorial Score
Nino's Pizzeria and Restaurant pizza
0
Italian-American

Nino's Pizzeria and Restaurant

Fort Myers, FL

Family recipes from New York roots, serving South Fort Myers since 1979.

9.4
Editorial Score
Lombardough's Pizza & Beer pizza
0
Wood-fired

Lombardough's Pizza & Beer

Fort Myers, FL

Bold wood-fired pies paired with a solid craft beer list.

9.2
Editorial Score
Grimaldi's Pizzeria pizza
0
Coal-fired

Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Fort Myers, FL

Bell Tower Shops outpost of the famed coal-fired pizzeria chain.

8.9
Editorial Score
Uncle Rico's Pizza pizza
0
Traditional

Uncle Rico's Pizza

Fort Myers, FL

Small counter-service shop serving classic pizza in Fort Myers.

8.7
Editorial Score
Pizza Pub Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria pizza
0
Italian-American

Pizza Pub Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Fort Myers, FL

Myerlee Square standby for homemade Italian dishes and hand-tossed pizza.

8.5
Editorial Score
Coozy Pizza pizza
0
Artisan

Coozy Pizza

Fort Myers, FL

New stone-oven artisan pizza spot with a laid-back neighborhood vibe.

8.3
Editorial Score
McGregor Pizza Company pizza
0
Traditional

McGregor Pizza Company

Fort Myers, FL

Brick-oven pizza and hero sandwiches on Fort Myers' historic McGregor Boulevard.

8.1
Editorial Score
Downtown House of Pizza pizza
0
New York

Downtown House of Pizza

Fort Myers, FL

Downtown Fort Myers shop built around fresh, real-flavor New York-style pizza.

7.8
Editorial Score
Mangia Bene Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria pizza
0
Italian-American

Mangia Bene Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria

Fort Myers, FL

Cleveland Avenue Italian spot known for its wide pizza and pasta menu.

7.6
Editorial Score