Best pizza in New York · Sicilian & Square guide
Best Sicilian & Square Pizza in New York
The 4 best Sicilian & Square pizzerias in New York, New York, ranked by editorial score. The thick, pillowy square slice — focaccia-like crumb, crisp fried bottom, and a generous layer of sauce and cheese. A bakery tradition from Palermo that found a second home in New York.
1
Sicilian
Mama's Too
New York, NY
Upper West Side square-slice phenom.
9.5
Editorial Score
2
Sicilian
Prince Street Pizza
New York, NY
The definitive Nolita square slice — pepperoni cups on a spongy, sauce-first crust.
9.3
Editorial Score
3
Sicilian
Prince Street Pizza
New York, NY
Nolita's pepperoni square — cupped, crisped, and unapologetic.
9.0
Editorial Score
4
Sicilian
Mama's Too
New York, NY
Upper West Side square-slice destination — spicy vodka pie is a religion.
8.8
Editorial Score