West Virginia · By City
Best Pizza in Fayetteville
The most essential pies in Fayetteville, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team. We currently rank 2 pizzerias here, led by American-style pies.
- Ranked
- Top 2
- High score
- 9.5
- On the map
- 2
List last updated October 2026
#1 in Fayetteville
Pies & Pints
American · Editorial score 9.5
Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.
Fayetteville pizza FAQ
What is the best pizza in Fayetteville?
Our editorial team currently ranks Pies & Pints as the best pizza in Fayetteville, West Virginia. Beloved West Virginia pizzeria known for the grape-and-gorgonzola pie.
What style of pizza is Fayetteville known for?
American is the most common style among our ranked Fayetteville pizzerias (2 of 2). The top-rated American spot is Pies & Pints.
How many pizza places does Great Pizza Places rank in Fayetteville?
We currently rank the top 2 pizza places in Fayetteville, West Virginia, scored on crust, sauce, cheese, ingredients, and consistency.
How does Great Pizza Places rank pizzerias in Fayetteville?
Every Fayetteville pizzeria is reviewed on five criteria — crust, sauce, cheese, ingredients, and consistency — combined into an editorial score from 0 to 10. Rankings are updated as we revisit and add new places.