Great Pizza Places

Texas · By City

Best Pizza in Amarillo

The most essential pies in Amarillo, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team. We currently rank 3 pizzerias here, with Artisan and New York leading the scene — scored on crust, sauce, cheese, ingredients, and consistency.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Fire Slice Pizzeria pizza
1
Artisan

Fire Slice Pizzeria

Amarillo, TX

Brick-oven pies are paired with a thoughtful wine list from a sommelier owner. Local toppings and house-made Italian sausage set them apart.

8.9
Editorial Score
Big Jim's Pizza Co. pizza
2
New York

Big Jim's Pizza Co.

Amarillo, TX

The longtime Amarillo staple, formerly La Bella Pizza, wins fans with a foldable crust and house-made meatballs. A full bar and covered patio round it out.

8.6
Editorial Score
575° Pizzeria pizza
3
Artisan

575° Pizzeria

Amarillo, TX

Hand-tossed thin crusts and a hearty house tomato sauce anchor the menu. A craft beer and wine bar makes it a social night out.

8.1
Editorial Score

More pizza in Texas

Best in El PasoBest in AustinBest in DallasBest in Fort WorthBest in San AntonioBest in ArlingtonBest in HoustonBest in IrvingAll cities →