Nebraska · By City

Best Pizza in Omaha

The most essential pies in Omaha, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team. We currently rank 17 pizzerias here, with New York and Neapolitan leading the scene.

Ranked: Top 17
High score: 9.5
On the map: 17

List last updated October 2026

#1 in Omaha

Noli's Pizzeria

New York · Editorial score 9.5

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

New York

Noli's Pizzeria

Omaha, NE

New York-trained pizzaiolo slinging foldable slices in Omaha.

9.5

Editorial Score

Neapolitan

Dante Pizzeria Napoletana

Omaha, NE

VPN-certified Neapolitan pies with a bright, blistered crust.

9.4

Editorial Score

Neapolitan

Pitch Pizzeria

Omaha, NE

Blistered Neapolitan pies from a hip Dundee mainstay.

9.4

Editorial Score

Sicilian

Orsi's Italian Bakery

Omaha, NE

Century-old Little Italy bakery famous for Sicilian slabs.

9.3

Editorial Score

Traditional

Orsi's Italian Bakery & Pizzeria

Omaha, NE

Little Italy institution since 1919 with a beloved cracker-thin crust.

9.3

Editorial Score

Neapolitan

Dante Pizzeria Napoletana

Omaha, NE

Certified Neapolitan pies with wood-fired blister and pull.

9.2

Editorial Score

New York

Zio's Pizzeria

Omaha, NE

NY-style slice shop with a foldable crust since 1985.

9.1

Editorial Score

New York

Zio's Pizzeria

Omaha, NE

Old-school New York-style slices in the Old Market.

9.1

Editorial Score

New York

Noli's Pizzeria

Omaha, NE

Old Market foldable NY pies with a proper crust.

9.0

Editorial Score

Traditional

La Casa Pizzaria

Omaha, NE

Omaha institution since 1953 with a legendary romano-cheese crust.

8.8

Editorial Score

American

Big Fred's Pizza Garden

Omaha, NE

Old-school Omaha pizzeria with a cult following.

8.7

Editorial Score

Detroit

Pizza Shoppe Collective

Omaha, NE

Detroit-style pan slices with a shattering frico.

8.7

Editorial Score

Traditional

Big Fred's Pizza

Omaha, NE

Bellevue institution with a beloved cracker-thin crust.

8.6

Editorial Score

Italian-American

Mama Lucia's

Omaha, NE

Family-run Italian with a hand-tossed pie.

8.6

Editorial Score

New York

Sgt. Peffer's Cafe Italian

Omaha, NE

Family-run NY-style pies with a serious pepperoni.

8.4

Editorial Score

New York

Piezano's

Omaha, NE

West Omaha NY slice shop with foldable pies.

8.3

Editorial Score

Neapolitan

Mangia Italiana

Omaha, NE

Wood-fired Neapolitan pies with imported ingredients.

8.1

Editorial Score

Omaha pizza by style

Best New York in Omaha (6)Best Neapolitan in Omaha (4)Best Italian-American in Omaha (4)

Omaha pizza FAQ

What is the best pizza in Omaha?

Our editorial team currently ranks Noli's Pizzeria as the best pizza in Omaha, Nebraska. New York-trained pizzaiolo slinging foldable slices in Omaha.

What style of pizza is Omaha known for?

New York is the most common style among our ranked Omaha pizzerias (6 of 17). The top-rated New York spot is Noli's Pizzeria.

How many pizza places does Great Pizza Places rank in Omaha?

We currently rank the top 17 pizza places in Omaha, Nebraska, scored on crust, sauce, cheese, ingredients, and consistency.

How does Great Pizza Places rank pizzerias in Omaha?

Every Omaha pizzeria is reviewed on five criteria — crust, sauce, cheese, ingredients, and consistency — combined into an editorial score from 0 to 10. Rankings are updated as we revisit and add new places.

More pizza in Nebraska

Best in Lincoln All cities →