Great Pizza Places

Missouri · By City

Best Pizza in Columbia

The most essential pies in Columbia, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Shakespeare's Pizza Downtown pizza
0
Tavern

Shakespeare's Pizza Downtown

Columbia, MO

A Mizzou institution since 1973 dishing out thick, cheesy pies best eaten on the patio.

9.6
Editorial Score
Shakespeare's Pizza South pizza
0
Tavern

Shakespeare's Pizza South

Columbia, MO

Same beloved crust and sauce as downtown, minus the campus crowds.

9.5
Editorial Score
Angelo's Pizza & Steak House pizza
0
Italian-American

Angelo's Pizza & Steak House

Columbia, MO

A neighborhood standby pairing gyros and steaks with a reliably cheesy pizza.

9.3
Editorial Score
Southside Pizza & Pub pizza
0
Tavern

Southside Pizza & Pub

Columbia, MO

Late-night sports-bar pizza built for post-game and post-bar cravings.

9.2
Editorial Score
Pizza Tree pizza
0
Artisan

Pizza Tree

Columbia, MO

Quirky specialty pies with punny names and a devoted downtown following.

9.0
Editorial Score
Tony's Pizza Palace pizza
0
Italian-American

Tony's Pizza Palace

Columbia, MO

A 60-year-old family-run staple famous for its crisp crust and Greek sides.

8.9
Editorial Score
D. Rowe's Restaurant & Bar pizza
0
Tavern

D. Rowe's Restaurant & Bar

Columbia, MO

Better known for wings, but this south Columbia hangout's pizza punches above its weight.

8.7
Editorial Score
Endwell Taverna pizza
0
New York

Endwell Taverna

Columbia, MO

A 2025 newcomer in the Old Jail building serving Brooklyn-style pies from an NYC chef.

8.6
Editorial Score
Gumby's Pizza pizza
0
Tavern

Gumby's Pizza

Columbia, MO

Late-night Mizzou staple famous for oversized pies and the Original Pokey Stix.

8.4
Editorial Score
Shakespeare's Pizza West pizza
0
Tavern

Shakespeare's Pizza West

Columbia, MO

The newest Shakespeare's outpost bringing the chain's signature crust to west Columbia.

8.3
Editorial Score