Great Pizza Places

Michigan · By City

Best Pizza in Kalamazoo

The most essential pies in Kalamazoo, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Bilbo's Pizza & Brewing Co pizza
0
Italian-American

Bilbo's Pizza & Brewing Co

Kalamazoo, MI

The crust is medium-thick with a good chew, holding well under a generously portioned combo pie. Their house brewed beer pairs nicely with the mildly sweet house sauce.

9.1
Editorial Score
Erbelli's pizza
0
Artisan

Erbelli's

Kalamazoo, MI

The crust is well-fermented with a nice chew and a slightly crisp bottom, built to support inventive gourmet topping combos. Sauce is well-balanced, not overly sweet, letting speci

9.0
Editorial Score
Maestro's Pizza pizza
0
Italian-American

Maestro's Pizza

Kalamazoo, MI

The crust benefits from bakery-fresh dough and imported cheeses, giving a rich, well-rounded bite. The house-made sausage topping stands out against a well-seasoned sauce.

8.9
Editorial Score
Bimbo's Pizza pizza
0
Sicilian

Bimbo's Pizza

Kalamazoo, MI

The thick, airy Sicilian-style crust has a satisfying crunch on the bottom while staying soft inside. Sauce is applied on top of the cheese in classic Sicilian fashion, tangy and r

8.8
Editorial Score
Roma's Pizza Kalamazoo pizza
0
Italian-American

Roma's Pizza Kalamazoo

Kalamazoo, MI

The crust is medium-thick, consistent, and holds up well under heavier toppings like the loaded potato-topped specialty pie. Sauce is simple and reliable rather than adventurous.

8.7
Editorial Score
Kazoopy's Pizza & Grinders pizza
0
Craft

Kazoopy's Pizza & Grinders

Kalamazoo, MI

The crust is solid enough to support unusual combos like their dill pickle pizza, holding structure without getting soggy. Sauce and cheese blends are customizable, appealing to ad

8.5
Editorial Score
Portage Road Pizza pizza
0
Italian-American

Portage Road Pizza

Kalamazoo, MI

The crust bakes evenly with a decent crisp bottom, holding up under classic combo toppings. Sauce is straightforward tomato-based without much sweetness.

8.4
Editorial Score
Fieldstone Grill Pizza pizza
0
Californian

Fieldstone Grill Pizza

Kalamazoo, MI

The thin crust is baked at high heat for good char, a solid base for the grill's more inventive topping combinations. It leans more toward hearty portions than delicate technique.

8.3
Editorial Score
Bacchus Wine Bar Pizza pizza
0
Artisan

Bacchus Wine Bar Pizza

Kalamazoo, MI

The thin, crisp flatbread crust is designed to pair with wine, staying light rather than heavy. Toppings are minimal and high-quality, letting the crust and cheese speak for themse

8.2
Editorial Score