Great Pizza Places

Illinois · By City

Best Pizza in Peoria

The most essential pies in Peoria, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Agatucci's Restaurant pizza
0
Italian-American

Agatucci's Restaurant

Peoria, IL

Family-owned Peoria institution serving pizza since 1926.

9.6
Editorial Score
Tyroni's Pizza pizza
0
Traditional

Tyroni's Pizza

Peoria, IL

Family restaurant since 1986 with fresh dough made daily.

9.4
Editorial Score
Brienzo's Pizza + Bar pizza
0
Craft

Brienzo's Pizza + Bar

Peoria, IL

Fast-casual gourmet pizza and cocktails with a lively bar scene.

9.2
Editorial Score
Nick-N-Willy's Pizza pizza
0
Take-and-Bake

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza

Peoria, IL

Take-and-bake pizzeria known for creative topping combos.

8.9
Editorial Score
Kirov Vodka Bar & Pizzeria pizza
0
Artisan

Kirov Vodka Bar & Pizzeria

Peoria, IL

Riverfront spot pairing craft pizzas with an extensive vodka list.

8.7
Editorial Score
Emack & Bolio's/Sugar Momma's Pizza pizza
0
Traditional

Emack & Bolio's/Sugar Momma's Pizza

Peoria, IL

Neighborhood pizzeria near Bradley University popular with students.

8.5
Editorial Score
Vonachen's Junction pizza
0
Italian-American

Vonachen's Junction

Peoria, IL

Longtime Peoria dining spot with classic Italian-American pizza.

8.3
Editorial Score
Old Chicago Pizza pizza
0
Deep Dish

Old Chicago Pizza

Peoria, IL

Chain favorite for Chicago-style deep dish and a huge beer selection.

8.1
Editorial Score
Sisters Pizza pizza
0
Tavern

Sisters Pizza

Peoria, IL

Cozy tavern-style pizzeria loved by Peoria locals.

7.8
Editorial Score
Neisen's Pizza pizza
0
Traditional

Neisen's Pizza

Peoria, IL

Classic Peoria pizza shop with a devoted regular clientele.

7.6
Editorial Score