Great Pizza Places

Georgia · By City

Best Pizza in Athens

The most essential pies in Athens, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Little Italy Pizzeria pizza
0
Italian-American

Little Italy Pizzeria

Athens, GA

Longtime downtown fixture serving classic Italian-American pies since 1997.

9.6
Editorial Score
Ted's Most Best pizza
0
New York

Ted's Most Best

Athens, GA

Late-night downtown slice shop popular with the UGA crowd.

9.4
Editorial Score
Pompeii pizza
0
Wood-fired

Pompeii

Athens, GA

Modern Italian dining just off College Square with wood-fired pizzas.

9.2
Editorial Score
Mellow Mushroom Athens pizza
0
Craft

Mellow Mushroom Athens

Athens, GA

Downtown staple for stuffed calzones and specialty pies.

8.9
Editorial Score
Killer Crust Pizza pizza
0
Artisan

Killer Crust Pizza

Athens, GA

Under-the-radar suburban spot earning a cult following for craft pies.

8.7
Editorial Score
ZZ & Simone's pizza
0
Italian-American

ZZ & Simone's

Athens, GA

Casual Italian spot near campus with a loyal pizza following.

8.5
Editorial Score
Automatic Pizza pizza
0
New York

Automatic Pizza

Athens, GA

Normaltown slice shop turning out New York-style pies, subs and cannoli.

8.3
Editorial Score
Athens Pizza pizza
0
Italian-American

Athens Pizza

Athens, GA

Hand-stretched, fire-kissed pizzas alongside wings and subs in Athens.

8.1
Editorial Score
Mama Sid's Pizza pizza
0
Traditional

Mama Sid's Pizza

Athens, GA

Independent neighborhood pizzeria beloved for generous, classic pies.

7.8
Editorial Score
Mellow Mushroom pizza
0
Craft

Mellow Mushroom

Athens, GA

Downtown Athens outpost of the Georgia-born stoned-crust pizza chain.

7.6
Editorial Score