Great Pizza Places

Colorado · By City

Best Pizza in Fort Collins

The most essential pies in Fort Collins, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza pizza
0
Wood-fired

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza

Fort Collins, CO

Family favorite for wood-fired pies and pasta with gluten-free crust options.

9.6
Editorial Score
Pizza Casbah pizza
0
New York

Pizza Casbah

Fort Collins, CO

Fort Collins' longtime authentic NYC-style pizzeria since 1999.

9.4
Editorial Score
Fuego Pizza Company pizza
0
Craft

Fuego Pizza Company

Fort Collins, CO

Old Town pizzeria crafting bold pies with fresh ingredients and time-honored technique.

9.2
Editorial Score
Postcard Pan Pizza pizza
0
Detroit

Postcard Pan Pizza

Fort Collins, CO

Detroit-inspired pan pizza pop-up turned brick-and-mortar known for crispy cheese edges.

8.9
Editorial Score
Beau Jo's pizza
0
Traditional

Beau Jo's

Fort Collins, CO

Colorado institution famous for thick mountain pies served with honey for the crust.

8.7
Editorial Score
Pulcinella Pizzeria & Wine Bar pizza
0
Italian-American

Pulcinella Pizzeria & Wine Bar

Fort Collins, CO

Fort Collins fixture since 1991 serving scratch-made Italian pies and pastas.

8.5
Editorial Score
Tony's Bar & Rooftop pizza
0
New York

Tony's Bar & Rooftop

Fort Collins, CO

Old Town institution serving NYC-style pizza by the slice on its rooftop patio by day.

8.3
Editorial Score
Krazy Karl's Pizza pizza
0
Tavern

Krazy Karl's Pizza

Fort Collins, CO

Late-night local chain favorite for cheap, generously topped pizza and wings.

8.1
Editorial Score