Great Pizza Places

California · By City

Best Pizza in Modesto

The most essential pies in Modesto, ranked by the Great Pizza Places editorial team. We currently rank 3 pizzerias here, with New York and Italian-American leading the scene — scored on crust, sauce, cheese, ingredients, and consistency.

Click a pin to preview the review, or hover a card to find it on the map.

Sacred Slice pizza
1
New York

Sacred Slice

Modesto, CA

Lines form minutes after opening for crunchy-yet-soft New York and Detroit pies. Hours are short, but simple quality ingredients justify the wait.

8.7
Editorial Score
Famiglia Bistro pizza
2
Italian-American

Famiglia Bistro

Modesto, CA

A white-tablecloth room turns pizza night into a full Italian dinner. Attentive service and generous portions make it a celebration favorite.

8.3
Editorial Score
Nizario's Pizza & Grill pizza
3
Californian

Nizario's Pizza & Grill

Modesto, CA

Unusual pies like the Mediterranean and Mr. Potato come from a hands-on owner. Late hours make it Modesto's after-midnight answer.

8.1
Editorial Score

More pizza in California

Best in San FranciscoBest in Los AngelesBest in San JoseBest in San DiegoBest in SacramentoBest in FresnoBest in Long BeachBest in OaklandAll cities →