Best pizza in Indianapolis · New York guide
Best New York Pizza in Indianapolis
The 4 best New York pizzerias in Indianapolis, Indiana, ranked by editorial score. Large, thin, and foldable — the slice that built America's pizza culture. A crisp-yet-pliable crust, a balanced tomato sauce, and low-moisture mozzarella, sold by the slice and eaten on the move.
1
New York
Some Guys Pizza
Indianapolis, IN
Broad Ripple foldable NY slice destination with a cult following.
9.3
Editorial Score
2
New York
Brozinni Pizzeria
Indianapolis, IN
South-side NY slice shop with foldable pies and a serious pepperoni.
8.7
Editorial Score
3
New York
Brozinni Pizzeria
Indianapolis, IN
Massive NY-style slices in the SoBro neighborhood.
0.0
Editorial Score
4
New York
Some Guys Pizza
Indianapolis, IN
Neighborhood spot known for thin-crust pies and Italian classics.
0.0
Editorial Score