Best pizza in Fayetteville · Italian-American guide
Best Italian-American Pizza in Fayetteville
The 8 best Italian-American pizzerias in Fayetteville, North Carolina, ranked by editorial score. The red-sauce pizzeria tradition carried across America by Italian immigrants: generous cheese, a sturdy crust, and recipes passed down for generations. This is the neighborhood pizza most of the country grew up on.
Capri Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
A longtime Bragg Boulevard favorite for strombolis, pastas, and hearty pizzas.
Elizabeth's Pizza & Restaurant
A regional mini-chain favorite where fans rave more about the wings than the crust, but both deliver.
Elizabeth's Pizza Hope Mills
Superior ingredients and traditional technique keep this Hope Mills location a local staple.
Litty's Pizza
Garlic knots and generously topped pies earn Litty's a steady stream of five-star praise.
Pizza Palace
A no-frills neighborhood parlor serving classic pizza to the Hope Mills Road corridor.
Romeo's Pizza
Famous for its sweet house sauce, Romeo's is a longtime contender for Fayetteville's best pie.
Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville
A colorful, patio-equipped outpost of the Southern chain popular with the McPherson Church crowd.
Bella Pizza & Pasta
A family-run Raeford Road kitchen turning out generously portioned Italian-American pizza.