Best pizza in Evansville · Italian-American guide
Best Italian-American Pizza in Evansville
The 5 best Italian-American pizzerias in Evansville, Indiana, ranked by editorial score. The red-sauce pizzeria tradition carried across America by Italian immigrants: generous cheese, a sturdy crust, and recipes passed down for generations. This is the neighborhood pizza most of the country grew up on.
Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery
The crust is medium-thick and crisps nicely, standing up to house-brewed beer pairings. Sauce is well-balanced with a slight tang that complements generous topping portions.
Una-Tu Pizza
The thin-crust pies are cut into distinctive squares with a crisp edge. Sauce is simple and tomato-forward, letting classic pepperoni shine.
Rounders Pizza
The crust is thick enough to hold heavy toppings like their signature big meat combo without sagging. Sauce is straightforward and slightly sweet.
Sam's Pizza Evansville
The crust holds up well to a fully loaded 16-inch pie without getting soggy in the middle. Sauce has a mild sweetness typical of Evansville-style pizza.
Green River Pizzeria
The crust is medium-thick with a consistent bake and a mildly sweet house sauce. Classic sausage and pepperoni toppings are generously portioned.